Skip to main content

Previous

See you in court: a guide to court visits and protocol

Next

Civil process

great english trials

The trial of Clive Ponting (1985)

Andrew Mitchell introduces a trial that has become famous as an example of jury equity. Citizens had to assess competing claims of government secrecy and freedom of information relating to a controversial incident at a time of war

Clive Ponting’s case is especially relevant to the topic of juries in the lay person sections of the AQA and OCR specifications. It might, however, also stimulate discussion at A2, with the AQA Unit 4: Concepts of Law topics (especially law and morality, law and justice and balancing conflicting interests).

In April 1982 Argentina sent troops to invade the Falkland Islands. The UK government responded with military action, recapturing the islands by June of that year. As the 30th anniversary of the conflict has recently passed, and the dispute between Britain and Argentina continues to simmer, it seems timely to look again at the trial of Clive Ponting. This focused on perhaps the most controversial incident in the war: the sinking of an Argentinian ship, the General Belgrano, by a British submarine, resulting in the deaths of over 300 men.

Your organisation does not have access to this article.

Sign up today to give your students the edge they need to achieve their best grades with subject expertise

Subscribe

Previous

See you in court: a guide to court visits and protocol

Next

Civil process

Related articles: