Skip to main content

Previous

How federal is Trump’s America?

Next

Comparative politics: Congress vs Parliament

debate

Who should make the law — judges or elected representatives?

Louis Sugden and Matt Walker debate the question

The law of the land is made through a mixture of legislating, as performed by Parliament, and through the establishment of common and case law by judges. While judges cannot initiate new legislation that results in law, their decisions create rules and precedents that must be followed. This in effect means that they do ‘create laws’, or can be said to ‘legislate from the bench’.

Judges are better placed than elected representatives to make laws for a range of reasons:

Your organisation does not have access to this article.

Sign up today to give your students the edge they need to achieve their best grades with subject expertise

Subscribe

Previous

How federal is Trump’s America?

Next

Comparative politics: Congress vs Parliament

Related articles: